No Longer One Nation, Under God

11 09 2009


During the ’08 campaign, an essay written by Dennis Prager made a deep impression on me because it said out loud what increasingly was in my mind and heart: The left and right in America have become irreconcilable.

As Prager wrote then:

It is time to confront the unhappy fact about our country: There are now two Americas….

For most of my life I have believed, in what I now regard as wishful thinking, that the right and left wings have essentially the same vision for America, that it’s only about ways to get there in which the two sides differ. Right and left share the same ends, I thought.

That is not the case. For the most part, right and left differ in their visions of America and that is why they differ on policies.

Right and the left do not want the same America.

The latest pundit to say the same thing is Patrick Buchanan:

We seem not only to disagree with each other more than ever, but to have come almost to detest one another. Politically, culturally, racially, we seem ever ready to go for each others’ throats….

The question invites itself. In what sense are we one nation and one people anymore? For what is a nation if not a people of a common ancestry, faith, culture and language, who worship the same God, revere the same heroes, cherish the same history, celebrate the same holidays and share the same music, poetry, art and literature?

…Christmas and Easter, the great holidays of Christendom, once united Americans in joy. Now we fight over whether they should even be mentioned, let alone celebrated, in our public schools.

…One part of America loves her history, another reviles it as racist, imperialist and genocidal…. But the old holidays, heroes and icons endure, as the new have yet to put down roots in a recalcitrant Middle America.

We are not only more divided than ever on politics, faith and morality, but along the lines of class and ethnicity. Those who opposed Sonia Sotomayor for the Supreme Court and stood by Sgt. Crowley in the face-off with Harvard’s Henry Louis Gates were called racists. But this time they did not back down. They threw the same vile word right back in the face of their accusers, and Barack Obama.

Consider but a few issues on which Americans have lately been bitterly divided: school prayer, the Ten Commandments, evolution, the death penalty, abortion, homosexuality, assisted suicide, affirmative action, busing, the Confederate battle flag, the Duke rape case, Terri Schiavo, Iraq, amnesty, torture.

Now it is death panels, global warming, “birthers” and socialism. If a married couple disagreed as broadly and deeply as Americans do on such basic issues, they would have divorced and gone their separate ways long ago. What is it that still holds us together?

I believe that there is a fundamental and irreconcilable difference between conservatives and liberals.

Conservatives truly believe that in 1776 something remarkable happened — the founding of the United States of America. The American republic, though far from perfect — given the shameful treatment of the indigenous “Indians” and black slaves — nevertheless was something special in human history.  Conservatives therefore revere the Constitution and the Founding Fathers. We also believe that it is only because of American ideals as embodied in the Constitution that later reforms — emancipation of slaves and women, the civil rights movement — were even possible.

But conservatives are like the Ents in J.R.R. Tolkien’s Lord of the Rings. Revering what the Founding Fathers instituted, conservatives are by our nature not revolutionaries. And so, we became complacent — while the Left infiltrated and took over every institution in American society.

Liberals, however, especially the far Left, fixate on America’s imperfections, past and present, and in so doing create and embrace Identity Politics with its narcissistic permanent sense of aggrieved victimhood.

More importantly, instead of faulting flawed men who did not live up to the Declaration of Independence’s promise that all human beings “are created equal,” the Left blame “The System” — the very essence and institutions of the American republic for our problems and imperfections. They do not think something very special happened in 1776. They do not revere the Constitution or the Founding Fathers and, worshiping at the altar of radical feminism, insist that the latter be referred to as gender-neutral emasculated “Founders.”

The Left mean to destroy and transform America.

What to do then?

I don’t believe it is productive to lament this reality. Better that we be clear-eyed, for we can’t fix something if we can’t even name what’s wrong.

And the last thing conservatives should do is play nice because the Left don’t. Being the revolutionaries they are, they actually had known our differences are irreconcilable long before we did.

What we must do is:

  • Stand firm on our beliefs, ideals, and principles.
  • Inform and educate the American people.
  • Take back our schools, colleges, universities, and pop culture.
  • And fight, fight, fight to win elections at the national, state, and local levels, so that the Left, who are a numerical minority in the population, never again seize political power.

EntsThe Ents were slow to anger and to action. But when they finally realized that the very continuation of Middle-Earth was in peril, led by the great Treebeard, the Ents went to war.

We have numbers on our side because recent survey data say conservatives are an ideological majority, at 40%. We simply need to be energized and mobilized to action — which we are.

Our labor will be hard and unrelenting and unending. To do otherwise is to consign the American Republic to the trash-heap of history.




13 responses

11 09 2009

If only everyone in the country could read this post.


11 09 2009


You’re da man. I’m so grateful that you provide a forum for us on Giovanni’s World!

I offered my day — and an entire St. Michael’s chaplet — to you this morning.

Your friend, always,


11 09 2009

Great article, well written, to the point, on the money.

Yesterday I read, from blogroll above, 45 communist goals for America. Scary, but it describes the progression to the split your article describes.
I will be reading the essay by Dennis Prager you link to and the link to Patrick Buchanan.
Thank You.

11 09 2009

Thank you, Bob. I’m delighted to have found, not only a fellow conservative, but also a Lord of the Rings fan! 😉

12 09 2009
Many Nations, Under Whatever, Quite Divisible — Part ONE « New Wineskins

[…] Frequent commenter, friend and fellow blogger Eowyn wrote a post yesterday entitled, “No Longer One Nation, Under God” in which she […]

15 09 2009
Who Is John Galt

A very good article. I reposted it on my blog, , with credit to here of course.
Keep up the good fight!

15 09 2009

Who Is John Galt,

Thank you for posting “No Longer One Nation, Under God” on your blog. Conservatives and libertarians (as I assume you are, given your alias) need to know that our differences with the Left, esp. the far-Left, are irreconcilable. The sooner we realize this, the better.

I just love the title of your post, “Two Americas: The Awakening of the Ents.” Wish I’d thought of it! Great alias, too 😉

I fixed the URL for your alias, Who Is John Galt (it’s blogspot, not blogspace) so that others can visit Goodsense.

Upwards and onwards, my fellow warrior 😉

15 09 2009
A Fractured Nation? Destruction From Within….. « Romanticpoet’s Weblog

[…] essay from Eowyn at Giovanni’s World succintly sums up the new American reality America […]

15 09 2009

Followed this link and read a bunch, clicked on link there and read a bunch more, all informative and indicative that there are good americans out there. I believe in the pledge of allegiance. Saying it when I was in school gave me pride in this country. The battle to stop saying it in school sounds alot like when the battle to stop prayer in school took place.
I then followed a link from that page to the Obama files, ,
HOORAY, APPLAUSE, THANK GOD!!!! Everyone should go to this site and read the latest news posted here on 9/14 and 9/15 2009. It put a big smile on my face. Hope I’m not speaking to soon, but, Goodbye Obama, and Goodbye Pelosi.

15 09 2009
Who Is John Galt?

Thanks for the correction, Eowyn. It was late… 🙂

We’re also starting up a health care blog at


9 01 2010
A Nation Divided « Fellowship of the Minds

[…] But the divide between conservative vs. liberal belief systems is irreconcilable. See my post of Sept. 11, 2009, “No Longer One Nation, Under God.” […]

24 10 2012
Time to shun all Obama supporters | Fellowship of the Minds

[…] is the size of the Grand Canyon. (See also a 2009 essay I wrote on the unbridgeable gap, “No Longer One Nation, Under God.” […]

12 07 2015
It is time for U.S. Christians to disobey unjust laws | Fellowship of the Minds

[…] See also “No Longer One Nation, Under God“. […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: